Mallory Hodge was a Follower in The Following. Formerly the girlfriend of Lance Tierney, she joined Joe Carroll's movement as part of the Korban Cult. She is one of several New Followers, along with Tilda, Lucas and Patrick.
In 2012, she went "off the grid" with her boyfriend Lance. Prior to her disappearance, she was said to be inseparable from Lance (according to her parents) and lost her job at a Brooklyn Restaurant due to missing her shifts sneaking off with him.
Following Joe's murder of Micah and Julia, he assumed leadership of the cult and created a new group of followers. Mallory was one of the new recruits, trusted to Joe by Robert. He led them into New York where first Tilda and Lucas claimed 4 victims, then Mallory and Patrick went on their own assignment.
Each follower was given a choice of their victims, with Mallory being the third to make a choice of where to do the killing. She chose the previous restaurant she worked at and went in with Patrick, sitting at the bar until she spotted a woman she intended to kill. Leaving Patrick at the bar, she followed the woman into the bathroom where she brandished a knife after struggling to get herself to pull it. The woman fought her off and ran, being caught by Patrick in the restaurant and held hostage while the police (led by Ryan Hardy) had him in their sights.
Mallory walked out, knife still in hand...given the option by Ryan to put an end to this and leave the cult returning to her parents that missed her. Mallory, despite Patrick's insistence, dropped her knife and intended to join Ryan but he threw the hostage down and slit Mallory's neck before being shot to death by the Mike Weston. Mallory bled out as Ryan tried to stop the bleeding, dying in his arms.
- She was extremely devoted to her boyfriend, Lance Tierney. She was willing to join Joe's movement as a killer and almost stabbed a woman due to this devotion, but ultimately chose an option to return to her parents instead (though she was killed by Patrick before making that a reality).